Neutrogena Smokey Kohl Eyeliner with Antioxidant Vitamin E, Water-Resistant & Smooth-Gliding Eyeliner Makeup, Dark Brown, 0.014 oz

This is the only eyeliner I've used for the past 2 years. I've tried others and this has exactly the smudged line that looks best on my top lid. And the color is great--I have brown eyes but it's hard to imagine an eye color this won't look on. My biggest fear is that they're going to stop manufacturing it because it's getting more difficult to find, which is why I usually buy 2-3 at time!

Best eyeliner, great color - doesn’t smudge

Love this eyeliner, it works for me who's always on the go so don't have time to keep going back putting on more & more.

Deep brown works well.does not stay to long but it works.

This eyeliner is a dream! The dark brown shade is softer than black, perfect for enhancing mature eyes. It glides on effortlessly, lasts all day, and blends beautifully for a smoky effect. A true gem in any kit!

This pencil is discontinued l am so disappointed l have used it for years.

Amazing eyeliner! Lasts all day! Love it

I normally love this product, but I can’t get the cap off the one I got recently. It’s worthless if I can’t open it.I have it set up to return the item and ordered a new one. Same problem. It cannot be opened. LOT12029CK01 is defective and should not be sold.